In 2008, it was Barack Obama. In 2020, it’s Pete Buttigieg.
Buttigieg, the 37-year-old, married gay mayor of South Bend, Indiana, is, at the moment, the hottest candidate in the Democratic presidential field — drawing rave reviews everywhere he goes.
That’s obviously a tough comparison for Buttigieg — or any Democratic politician — to live up to. After all, no matter what you think of Obama’s eight years as president, it’s impossible to deny his massive natural abilities as a candidate. And there are lots and lots of differences between the two men: one black, one white, one a top-tier candidate from day he announced, the other (still) a long-shot, etc.
But Scarborough is far from the only person raving about Buttigieg. Beginning with a star turn at a CNN-sponsored town hall at South by Southwest in Austin, Texas, earlier this month, praise for Mayor Pete has been bubbling up from every corner of the party. And all of that positive attention seems to be feeding on itself and producing tangible results for his campaign.
In short: Everything is falling into place for Buttigieg. (One thing that might bring him back down to earth? If Buttigieg has a less-than-impressive first quarter of fundraising — the deadline to raise cash is March 31.)
The reasons for the attention he’s drawing and excitement he’s creating aren’t hard to figure out; He’s young, charismatic and personable. He knows how to talk like a regular person — an underrated trait in a field filled with front-running senators. And he has a remarkable resume: Rhodes scholar, military veteran, gay mayor of his hometown.
Then there’s this: Buttigieg has ZERO expectations about how he will do in this race. When he started running, virtually no one outside of South Bend had even heard of him. When your candidacy isn’t weighed down by heavy expectations, you can play fast and loose. You don’t obsess over every little thing you say or do. Your every word isn’t parsed by the national news media. You can make a mistake (or two) without it being painted as a death blow for your candidacy.
And, this: People l-o-v-e a good underdog story. Sure, they might be drawn to the bigger names like Joe Biden and Beto O’Rourke, but Americans will never, ever not be drawn to a scrappy candidate who is charging at the big boys and demanding that he be included in their club. The spunky outsider is in our DNA. And Buttigieg fits that profile to a T.
Now. It’s March 21, 2019. No one will cast a vote in the primary process for 11-ish months. In that time, Buttigieg’s star could burn out. It could wax and wane. (Yes, I am confusing star and moon metaphors — but you get the idea.) In six months, we might look back and think he had his moment too soon.
It’s not at all clear whether Buttigieg and his team can make that leap. But it is clear that he has a chance, right now, to do so.